Daily 16:8 Versus Weekly 5:2 Intermittent Fasting for Weight Loss and Metabolic Health: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Study Details
This 4-week randomised trial compared daily 16:8 time-restricted eating with a 5:2 fasting approach in 68 women with overweight or obesity 🔍
The 16:8 group fasted for 16 h every day, while the 5:2 group consumed an ~800 kcal fasting-mimicking diet on 2 non-consecutive days/week ⏰
Key Findings
⚖️ Across both groups, body weight fell by ~2.7 kg, fat mass by ~1.7 kg and muscle mass by ~0.6 kg
📉 By week 4, weight loss was greater with 5:2: −3.13 kg vs −2.19 kg with 16:8
🔥 Fat loss was also greater with 5:2: −2.10 kg vs −1.23 kg
💪 Muscle mass declined similarly in both groups: −0.59 vs −0.56 kg
📏 Waist circumference fell by ~3.2 cm, with no meaningful difference between approaches
🫀 Systolic blood pressure decreased by ~6.7 mmHg overall, again with no significant difference between groups
🍽️ Importantly, neither group was prescribed a calorie deficit, yet energy intake spontaneously fell by around 530–550 kcal/day
🕐 The eating window shortened more with 16:8 (−3.3 h) than 5:2 (−1.3 h)
🩸 Mean glucose decreased similarly with both strategies, although peak glucose fell more with 16:8 while glucose nadir fell more with 5:2
⚠️ The study lasted only 4 weeks, included women only, used BIA for body composition, relied on self-reported dietary intake and did not measure physical activity
Conclusion
Both intermittent fasting approaches produced meaningful short-term weight and fat loss largely alongside reduced energy intake, with 5:2 producing greater fat loss by weeks 3–4 but no advantage for preserving muscle mass ✅
Reference
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/oby.70322

Performance Nutrition Digest is powered by Healthspan Elite ⚡️
Healthspan Elite is a science-led sports nutrition range developed in collaboration with leading experts to support athletic performance, recovery, and health.
Use code: TCDIGEST25 for 25% off at https://www.healthspanelite.co.uk/ 💪




