Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Guy Thibault's avatar

Cook, Bateman and Willems provide a useful account of anthocyanin-induced changes in substrate use during exercise. However, their own conclusion that New Zealand blackcurrant extract can increase fat oxidation β€œwithout alteration of total energy expenditure” sets a strict limit on any implication for body-weight management. [1]

A higher rate of fat oxidation during an exercise bout, especially when accompanied by lower carbohydrate oxidation, describes a change in fuel selection, not an increase in energy dissipation. It cannot by itself establish a net loss of adipose tissue. To make such a claim, one would need evidence of a sustained negative energy balance and, ultimately, of a negative fat balance or a change in body composition.

This is not a semantic distinction. The interpretation of respiratory quotient as an intrinsic ability to β€œburn fat” has been critically re-examined. In a review of 42 studies, PΓ©ronnet and Haman found no convincing experimental support for the proposition that low fat oxidation predisposes individuals to obesity. They also showed that, under a stable diet, 24-hour respiratory quotient is determined by food quotient and energy balance; fasting respiratory quotient additionally reflects glycogen stores. It is therefore not a direct measure of a person's innate capacity to oxidise fat. [2]

The same principle is illustrated by experimental work in rodents. Acute and chronic interventions that increased fatty-acid oxidation without increasing energy demand shifted oxidation away from glucose, but produced no net increase in energy expenditure or reduction in adiposity. [3] This reciprocal pattern is also prominent in the studies reviewed by Cook et al.

Anthocyanin supplementation may still deserve study in endurance sportβ€”for example, if glycogen sparing affects exercise tolerance or recovery. But a transient increase in fat oxidation is not evidence for fat loss. Research and public communication should therefore stop treating β€œmore fat burning” as a weight-loss target, and instead assess the outcomes that matter: energy intake, total energy expenditure, long-term fat balance, and body composition.

References

1.

Cook MD, Bateman JL, Willems MET. Anthocyanin-induced alterations in substrate oxidation during exercise: a narrative review. Nutrients. 2026;18(18):3018. doi:10.3390/nu18183018.

2.

PΓ©ronnet F, Haman F. Low capacity to oxidize fat and body weight. Obesity Reviews. 2019;20:1367–1383. doi:10.1111/obr.12910.

3.

Hoehn KL, Turner N, Swarbrick MM, et al. Acute or chronic upregulation of mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation has no net effect on whole-body energy expenditure or adiposity. Cell Metabolism. 2010;11:70–76. doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2009.11.008.

No posts

Ready for more?